what is required when a scrum team says a product backlog item is done

E Authors

2 min read

·

27-12-2024

56

0

Share

In Scrum, declaring a Product Backlog Item (PBI) "done" isn't simply a matter of completing the task; it signifies a much higher level of completion that ensures quality, value delivery, and team alignment. This article explores the criteria necessary to mark a PBI as "done," drawing upon insights from scientific literature and offering practical examples to enhance understanding.

Defining "Done": Beyond Task Completion

A common misconception is that "done" means merely finishing the assigned tasks within a sprint. However, a truly "done" PBI adheres to a pre-defined Definition of Done (DoD). This DoD, established collaboratively by the Scrum team, outlines the specific criteria that must be met before the increment is considered complete and ready for release.

This aligns with the principles outlined in several research papers on Scrum implementation. While Sciencedirect doesn't have a specific article solely on "Definition of Done," the underlying principles are discussed extensively in literature focusing on Scrum framework effectiveness and quality management within agile projects. For example, the importance of clear acceptance criteria (integral to a DoD) is emphasized in studies examining the impact of requirements clarity on project success [Citation needed - a relevant study would focus on the correlation between well-defined acceptance criteria and successful sprint completion. This would need to be found on Sciencedirect or similar academic databases].

Essential Components of a Robust Definition of Done:

A comprehensive DoD typically includes, but isn't limited to:

• Code Quality: The code must meet pre-defined coding standards, be well-documented, and pass all automated tests. This ensures maintainability and reduces technical debt. For example, a DoD might specify 100% code coverage with unit tests and adherence to a specific coding style guide (like PEP 8 for Python).

• Testing: Comprehensive testing, including unit, integration, and system testing, must be completed successfully. This verifies functionality and identifies potential bugs early. A practical example: a web application PBI might require successful completion of end-to-end tests simulating user interactions.

• Documentation: Appropriate documentation, such as user manuals, API specifications, or technical documentation, should be created and updated. Consider a PBI for developing a new API; the DoD would necessitate complete and accurate API documentation.

• Review and Approval: A formal code review and acceptance by the Product Owner or designated stakeholders are crucial. This ensures alignment between the developed functionality and the initial requirements. This could involve a demo and sign-off by the Product Owner.

• Deployment Readiness: The PBI must be ready for immediate deployment to the production environment (if applicable), including necessary deployment scripts and procedures. For instance, a DevOps-oriented DoD might stipulate automatic deployment to a staging environment and manual deployment to production after successful testing.

Benefits of a Well-Defined DoD:

• Improved Quality: Reduces defects and increases customer satisfaction.
• Enhanced Transparency: Creates a shared understanding of "done" across the team and stakeholders.
• Increased Predictability: Makes sprint planning and velocity estimation more accurate.
• Reduced Risk: Early detection of issues and faster resolution.
• Improved Collaboration: Fosters teamwork and shared responsibility.

Conclusion:

Defining "done" is a crucial step in successful Scrum implementation. Moving beyond a simplistic understanding of task completion and adopting a robust DoD that encompasses code quality, testing, documentation, review, and deployment readiness is paramount for delivering high-quality, valuable increments. By consistently applying a well-defined DoD, Scrum teams can enhance predictability, reduce risk, and ultimately deliver superior products. Regular review and adaptation of the DoD are necessary to maintain its relevance and effectiveness as the project and team evolve.