can cohen's d be negative

E Authors

2 min read

·

07-02-2025

22

0

Share

Cohen's d is a widely used measure of effect size, quantifying the standardized difference between two group means. But a question frequently arises: can Cohen's d be negative? The short answer is yes, and understanding why is crucial for correctly interpreting research findings. This article will explore this question, drawing upon insights from the community at CrosswordFiend (while acknowledging their contributions as the source of initial inspiration for some of the Q&A style used). We'll also delve deeper into the implications of a negative d value.

Understanding Cohen's d

Before addressing the negativity question, let's briefly review Cohen's d. It's calculated as:

d = (M₁ - M₂) / SD

Where:

• M₁ is the mean of the first group.
• M₂ is the mean of the second group.
• SD is a pooled standard deviation (a measure of the overall variability within both groups).

Can Cohen's d Be Negative? Yes!

The sign of Cohen's d simply indicates the direction of the effect, not its magnitude. A negative value means that the mean of the second group (M₂) is larger than the mean of the first group (M₁). In other words:

• Positive d: The first group has a higher mean than the second group.
• Negative d: The second group has a higher mean than the first group.

The absolute value of d represents the magnitude of the effect size – regardless of direction. A d of -0.8 has the same effect size as a d of 0.8; only the direction of the difference is reversed.

Example Scenario

Let's say we're comparing the test scores of two groups of students: a control group (Group 1) and an experimental group that received a new teaching method (Group 2).

• Scenario 1: If the control group has a mean score of 70 and the experimental group has a mean of 78, and the pooled SD is 10, then Cohen's d = (70 - 78) / 10 = -0.8. This indicates the experimental group performed better.

• Scenario 2: If the control group had a mean score of 78 and the experimental group had a mean score of 70, Cohen's d would be (78-70)/10 = +0.8, indicating the control group performed better.

Interpreting the Sign

The sign of Cohen's d is vital for understanding the direction of the effect. It's not inherently "good" or "bad" to have a positive or negative value; it simply shows which group scored higher. Researchers must choose which group to label as Group 1 and Group 2 carefully, ensuring clear communication of their findings. Often, the choice depends on the research hypothesis, with the hypothesized superior group being designated as Group 1. A negative result then indicates the hypothesis was incorrect.

Beyond the Basics: Considerations for Reporting

When reporting Cohen's d, clearly state:

• The value of d (including the sign).
• The groups being compared.
• The measure used to calculate the means and standard deviation.
• A clear statement explaining the meaning and implications of the effect size (e.g., "A Cohen's d of -0.8 indicates a large effect size, with the experimental group performing substantially better than the control group").

By understanding the meaning and implications of a negative Cohen's d, researchers can accurately interpret and report their findings, avoiding potential misinterpretations of the direction and magnitude of the effect size. Remember, the sign only indicates direction; the absolute value reveals the size of the effect.