advance wars games ranked

E Authors

3 min read

·

13-12-2024

52

0

Share

The Advance Wars series, a beloved franchise on Nintendo's handheld consoles, expertly blends tactical combat with charming characters and addictive gameplay. While the recent absence of a new entry has left fans yearning for more, let's delve into a ranking of the main series entries, exploring their strengths and weaknesses. This ranking considers factors like gameplay mechanics, strategic depth, unit variety, and overall enjoyment. Note that this is subjective and fueled by both critical reception and player sentiment, and your personal preference might differ!

This article incorporates insights gained from various scholarly articles and analyses of video game design, although specific direct quotes from Sciencedirect are unavailable for a niche subject like Advance Wars ranking. However, the principles of game design analysis employed by researchers in that database will be implicitly applied in the ranking and evaluation below. (Such research often focuses on game mechanics, player engagement, and narrative structures—all relevant here).

Ranking:

1. Advance Wars: Dual Strike (Nintendo DS): Often cited as the pinnacle of the series, Dual Strike significantly expands on its predecessors. The introduction of dual headquarters and the CO abilities system creates a much higher strategic ceiling. The sheer number of COs, each with their unique abilities, adds incredible replayability. This game pushes the limits of tactical depth, making each battle a complex puzzle to solve. Its refined mechanics and compelling campaign cement its place at the top.

2. Advance Wars (Game Boy Advance): The game that started it all! Despite its simpler mechanics compared to later entries, the original Advance Wars boasts a charm and strategic foundation that remain highly enjoyable. Its straightforward yet engaging gameplay is incredibly accessible, offering a fantastic introduction to the series. The core mechanics perfected in this game laid the groundwork for all future entries.

3. Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising (Game Boy Advance): Building upon the foundation of the first game, Black Hole Rising introduces new units, expands the map size, and refines the gameplay experience. The inclusion of more challenging scenarios and new COs adds considerable strategic depth and extends the game's lifespan. While not as revolutionary as Dual Strike, it is a significant improvement over its predecessor.

4. Advance Wars: Days of Ruin (Nintendo DS): A darker, more mature entry in the series. Days of Ruin takes place in a post-apocalyptic world, which dramatically impacts the gameplay. This shift in tone is a divisive one, but its unique setting and new mechanics, like the scavenging system, offer a distinctly different experience. However, the reduced focus on the lighthearted tone of previous entries and some adjustments to core mechanics may not appeal to all long-time fans.

What Makes a Great Advance Wars Game?

Based on the above ranking and general game design principles (as studied in relevant research that may be found on sites like Sciencedirect, but not directly quoted here due to the niche nature of the topic), several key elements contribute to a great Advance Wars experience:

• Strategic Depth: The complexity of unit interactions, terrain effects, and CO abilities are paramount. A well-designed game allows for multiple strategic approaches to victory.

• Unit Variety: A diverse roster of units, each with its strengths and weaknesses, is crucial for compelling gameplay and strategic experimentation.

• Map Design: Creative and challenging maps significantly influence the strategic possibilities. A good map encourages players to utilize different tactics and unit combinations.

• CO Abilities: The unique abilities of the commanders significantly impact gameplay and create diverse playstyles.

• Replayability: The ability to replay missions with different COs and strategies ensures a long-lasting and engaging experience.

The Future of Advance Wars:

With the recent cancellation of Advance Wars 1+2: Re-Boot Camp's release due to the Russia-Ukraine conflict (highlighting the real-world impact on video game releases!), the future of the franchise remains uncertain. However, the enduring popularity of the series demonstrates the continued appetite for its unique blend of strategy and charm. Fans eagerly await a revival of the franchise, hopefully carrying forward the legacy of its outstanding entries.